Debate over US Senate permitting bill carries echoes of California's Proposition 45
Published in News & Features
The U.S. Senate on Wednesday continued to advance legislation to speed permitting for a range of new projects under federal environmental statutes, most notably for both clean energy and fossil fuel infrastructure, with bipartisan support and the backing of President Donald Trump.
Democratic and Republican lawmakers backing the legislation seek to pass it before a wave of new, incoming lawmakers from the midterm sweep by Democrats reaches Congress — likely including more opponents to the legislation.
A final Senate vote could come as soon as Thursday, which would then return the bill to the U.S. House, where it originated. Senators have changed the legislation considerably and House approval is not guaranteed.
Environmental organizations, outdoor recreation groups and other conservation-minded constituencies nationwide are rallying against the legislation. They say passage would punch holes in longstanding bedrock protections like the National Environmental Protection Act and Endangered Species Act.
Also opposed are many of the nation’s tribal governments, who say the legislation as is degrades their sovereignty by lessening the requirements on developers to consult with tribes about sacred sites and historic ties to building sites.
Both bill proponents and opponents agree it represents one of the most sweeping changes to how the federal government permits consequential development projects in decades.
For Californians, the debate echoes strongly of the pitched electoral fight over California’s Proposition 45, a ballot measure which aimed to speed permitting decisions for eight categories of building projects through the California Environmental Quality Act. For one thing, the structure of the proposed changes are similar: The legislation seeks to accelerate permitting decisions by placing deadlines on federal agencies to either approve or reject proposed projects, and creating a time limit for legal challenges against those decisions. Like with Prop. 45, it also narrows the scope of what environmental reviews might entail.
The philosophical position behind the legislation, and the divide it’s driving among Democratic lawmakers, is also similar to Prop. 45. On one side are adherents of the argument that long-held positions of the political left, like strong environmental protections, have now strayed into creating bureaucratic hurdles to Democrats’ policy goals like combating climate change and building more affordable housing. On the other side are Democrats who say lawmakers can make strides toward those ends without changing key environmental laws.
All election season, proponents said California’s Prop. 45 would go far in addressing the state’s cost-of-living woes. Opponents argued it was a disguised effort to empower corporations over communities who object to development proposals.
Opponents of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA, as the congressional package is known, are making similar arguments.
“Buried within more than 400 pages of dense legislative text, the Senate permitting bill includes provisions that would put public lands on the chopping block, enable fast delivery of gas to fuel the artificial intelligence data center build-out, threaten historic and cultural sites, give handouts to oil and gas companies, lock in deep-sea mining for years to come, and codify illegal permits,” a call to action from the environmental legal organization Earthjustice said.
The California Native Plant Society called BAAJA, “another wolf in sheep’s clothing,” in a post comparing it to Prop. 45.
The state’s voters ultimately rejected Prop. 45, with nearly 57% of them voting against it.
BAAJA opponents are pointing to that vote, and to the effort to pass the bill ahead of the changeover in Congress, as a sign that lawmakers swayed by corporate interests are trying to speed the changes through over the will of voters.
“We don’t have to guess at where Californians are at on this federal permitting legislation,” said Shannon Olivieri Hovis, strategy officer for California Environmental Voters. Political strategists, she said, “would pay a lot of money for this kind of real time polling” offered by the vote on Prop. 45.
Olivieri Hovis described the election, in which voters ousted Republicans even in once-solidly red states like Texas, was an indication that people wanted prices lowered but also checks on the power of corporations. The election was “an overwhelming repudiation of Trump’s energy policies ... and his giveaways to corporate polluters.”
But BAAJA’s proponents say sweeping action is needed to break through the nation’s stilted permitting processes. California U.S. Sens. Adam Schiff and Alex Padilla have voted against it during procedural votes. But some California representatives in the House support the measure, including Rep. Scott Peters, D-La Jolla, said the bill would speed up electricity transmission projects that have long stalled and are critical to reducing carbon emissions.
Splitting Democrats
Bedrock environmental laws written decades ago have helped the nation improve its air and water quality, Peters said, but have now become roadblocks.
“Today if you want to fight the climate battle you have to build stuff,” he said. “You have to build transmission lines, offshore wind, utility-scale solar, hydrogen pipelines. That’s how you win the climate action fight.”
Peters interpreted the midterm results differently, saying voters ousted Republicans because the party in power had done little to blunt the rise of America’s cost of living. Voters are clamoring for measures that would drop the price of fuel and electricity, and BAAJA is the clearest path to doing so, he said.
And Trump, Peters noted, has indicated he’d sign the bill. It’s unclear whether the president would sign a different version of it once Democrats come into power in Congress next year, particularly as oversight investigations into Trump’s family and allies are likely to drive an antagonistic relationship.
“In Washington, the notion that we would have this opportunity to respond to that election by lowering costs and we would not take it, as Democrats, I think that would be a huge mistake,” he said.
Opposing Peters position is Northern California’s longtime environmentalist lawmaker Rep. Jared Huffman, D-San Rafael. The bill “could give Trump more room to push through his vanity projects, fast track massive AI data centers and hand fossil fuel companies another free pass,” Huffman said in a Nov. 10 post on X. “Congress still has a chance to say no to this bill as written. We should be making it easier to build clean energy and lower people’s bills, not making it easier to ignore tribes or anyone Big Oil thinks is in the way. We have to do better.”
Data centers and tribal objections
BAAJA’s opponents say there’s room for some reforms to federal environmental permitting, particularly to speed the development of wind and solar energy projects. But the legislation, they say, applies exemptions too sweepingly, including offshore oil drilling, mining operations and data centers. Those large computing warehouses have grown increasingly unpopular with voters across the political spectrum, and served as attack-ad ammunition in an array of midterm races.
The fight over Prop. 45 was one of them, as the two sides argued vehemently over whether the ballot measure included data centers. Opponents made the claim that it would help technology companies build them over community objections central to their campaign strategy.
BAAJA will speed permitting for data centers, though an increasing number of local governments have passed bans against them that appear likely to stand even if the legislation becomes law. Proponents note that the legislation includes provisions that require data center developers to pay more for the electricity they use, a measure they say addresses one of the chief objections to data centers — their impact on people’s electrical bills.
Peters agreed that BAAJA would apply the speeded permitting process to fossil fuel projects as well. But the demand for building renewable energy projects is higher than that for new fossil fuel installations like natural gas plants, he said. Those market forces would ultimately lead to a carbon emission drop, he argued. Proponents have predicted the legislation would lower emissions by 20% through 2035, but its detractors have questioned that number.
Representatives for the nation’s tribes were surprised by language that weakened requirements for the federal government to consult with tribal governments on permitting decisions to ensure places with spiritual significance aren’t needlessly destroyed.
“Tribal nations are sovereign governments, and it’s required that we have these consultations for a reason, especially when it comes to our cultural resources,” said Lycia Ortega, a citizen of Ft. Yuma Quechan Indian Tribe and a policy advocate who has been working to amend the legislation.
“We see something that was supposedly carefully crafted, and it literally is attacking our tribal sovereignty,” Ortega said.
Senators have sought to craft amendments that would protect the government-to-government consultations, but so far the vast majority of tribal organizations remain opposed to the bill. Tribal concerns have become a significant point of debate over BAAJA, and their continued opposition could peel away support in the House, particularly from western state lawmakers.
Peters, for his part, said he hoped for a resolution on that front, but would vote for the legislation even if tribes ultimately remain opposed.
“It’s a compromise bill,” he said. “I think we need to take it, get it behind us, and then you know work on what we want to do next in the next Congress.”
_____
©2026 The Sacramento Bee. Visit sacbee.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments