Politics

/

ArcaMax

POINT: If there were ever a good time for Supreme Court reform, this isn't it

Solomon D. Stevens, InsideSources.com on

Published in Political News

The Supreme Court just began a new term, and the calls for its reform by Democrats are increasing. Pete Buttigieg has made this a central part of his likely 2028 presidential run. He points to many people’s concerns about the court, but this is a really bad time to consider radical reform.

He has made three major proposals: increase the number of justices from nine to 13, set term limits, and require a “balanced bench.” All three of these proposals are problematic.

First, most people believe the Constitution sets the number of justices at nine, but it does not. Congress can change the number of justices by a simple majority vote.

Buttigieg says it would be good if the number of justices could correspond to the 13 federal judicial districts. This really makes no sense. There is no reason the number of justices should match the number of federal judicial districts. The likeliest explanation is that Buttigieg pulled 13 out of his hat to overturn what has become a conservative majority on the court. While that might sound attractive to Democrats frustrated with the court, reform of this magnitude shouldn’t be driven by partisan reasons.

His second proposal is to impose term limits on Supreme Court justices. Some have suggested that this would require 18-year staggered terms. Congress cannot do this by simple majority vote, since the Constitution states that Supreme Court justices (as well as all other federal judges) shall hold their offices “during good behavior.” Impeachment is the only constitutional way to remove a justice or a federal judge from office.

However, some believe this could be accomplished without a constitutional amendment by letting the justices keep their jobs and pay, but not allowing them to rule on decisions. No. The Constitution’s requirement that they hold their offices “during good behavior” does not mean they can keep their offices but not act as justices. Suggesting otherwise is nothing more than a willful misinterpretation of Article III.

And third, Buttigieg proposes something called a “balanced bench.” Under this proposal, 10 justices would be chosen through the senatorial confirmation process, but they would be “balanced” between Democratic and Republican presidents. The court would have to be expanded to 15 justices, with the Supreme Court justices picking the last five as “consensus” justices. Well, I’m sorry. This is just wacky. To begin with, how could you demand that the first 10 justices be balanced? Then, what possible definition of “consensus” justices would be safe from ideological manipulation?

It is true that the Senate’s confirmation process has become a partisan battleground, but why should we think this proposal will help eliminate partisanship? Beyond that, the Democratic Party and the Republican Party are always evolving. Right now, Democrats think the court is being poisoned by Republican control. Some will say the Democrats can be just as toxic. Certainly, no one can predict the future.

Both parties can act unwisely. You will not have a better court by hoping that highly partisan Democrats and highly partisan Republicans can be “managed” by a change in an institution. Think of the laws that have attempted to manage campaign finance. Every new law produces a new workaround, and the abuses continue. And no one can predict how reforming the Supreme Court would work in practice.

 

And then there is another interesting twist on all of this. If Congress passes term limits or a so-called balanced bench, these new laws would almost certainly go before the court as currently configured. And they could very well hold that the reforms are unconstitutional. This could lead to real, national unrest.

Our Founders were wise, and the Constitution they wrote was, I believe, one of the most remarkable documents in human history. However, they were fallible, and times change. In their wisdom, they included a way to amend the Constitution. We have already done so 27 times. If the American people want to reform the court and if a broad, national consensus allows for ratification, then the American people will have spoken, whether or not the reforms are wise. That is the way democratic republics work.

Trying to circumvent the Constitution to change the court is dangerous. Partisan reforms will not create a more balanced court — not as long as the nation remains deeply polarized, with each party seeing the other as a threat to the country’s existence.

_____

ABOUT THE WRITER

Solomon D. Stevens is the author of “Religion, Politics, and the Law” (co-authored with Peter Schotten) and “Challenges to Peace in the Middle East.” He wrote this for InsideSources.com.

_____


©2026 Tribune Content Agency, LLC

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

 

Related Channels

The ACLU

ACLU

By The ACLU
Armstrong Williams

Armstrong Williams

By Armstrong Williams
Austin Bay

Austin Bay

By Austin Bay
Betsy McCaughey

Betsy McCaughey

By Betsy McCaughey
Bill Press

Bill Press

By Bill Press
Bonnie Jean Feldkamp

Bonnie Jean Feldkamp

By Bonnie Jean Feldkamp
Cal Thomas

Cal Thomas

By Cal Thomas
Clarence Page

Clarence Page

By Clarence Page
Danny Tyree

Danny Tyree

By Danny Tyree
David Harsanyi

David Harsanyi

By David Harsanyi
Dick Polman

Dick Polman

By Dick Polman
Erick Erickson

Erick Erickson

By Erick Erickson
Froma Harrop

Froma Harrop

By Froma Harrop
Jacob Sullum

Jacob Sullum

By Jacob Sullum
Jamie Stiehm

Jamie Stiehm

By Jamie Stiehm
Jeff Robbins

Jeff Robbins

By Jeff Robbins
Jessica Johnson

Jessica Johnson

By Jessica Johnson
Jim Hightower

Jim Hightower

By Jim Hightower
Joe Conason

Joe Conason

By Joe Conason
John Stossel

John Stossel

By John Stossel
Josh Hammer

Josh Hammer

By Josh Hammer
Judge Andrew P. Napolitano

Judge Andrew Napolitano

By Judge Andrew P. Napolitano
Laura Hollis

Laura Hollis

By Laura Hollis
Marc Munroe Dion

Marc Munroe Dion

By Marc Munroe Dion
Michael Barone

Michael Barone

By Michael Barone
Mona Charen

Mona Charen

By Mona Charen
Rachel Marsden

Rachel Marsden

By Rachel Marsden
Rich Lowry

Rich Lowry

By Rich Lowry
Robert B. Reich

Robert B. Reich

By Robert B. Reich
Ruben Navarrett Jr.

Ruben Navarrett Jr

By Ruben Navarrett Jr.
Ruth Marcus

Ruth Marcus

By Ruth Marcus
S.E. Cupp

S.E. Cupp

By S.E. Cupp
Salena Zito

Salena Zito

By Salena Zito
Star Parker

Star Parker

By Star Parker
Stephen Moore

Stephen Moore

By Stephen Moore
Susan Estrich

Susan Estrich

By Susan Estrich
Ted Rall

Ted Rall

By Ted Rall
Terence P. Jeffrey

Terence P. Jeffrey

By Terence P. Jeffrey
Tim Graham

Tim Graham

By Tim Graham
Tom Purcell

Tom Purcell

By Tom Purcell
Veronique de Rugy

Veronique de Rugy

By Veronique de Rugy
Victor Joecks

Victor Joecks

By Victor Joecks
Wayne Allyn Root

Wayne Allyn Root

By Wayne Allyn Root

Comics

Clay Bennett A.F. Branco Tom Stiglich John Cole Mike Beckom Joel Pett